Arroyo Toad County Wide Monitoring

Surveys for arroyo toad have been conducted across San Diego County by various biologists from federal and state agencies, educational institutions, and non-governmental organizations. For over 20 years the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) has been one of the agencies conducting various arroyo toad studies throughout San Diego County in collaboration with other agencies and academic partners. Since 2000, USGS has conducted various monitoring and inventory surveys to determine the status of the species on conserved lands (Brown and Fisher 2002, Ervin, Hathaway, and Fisher 2002, Meyer et al. 2003, Hitchcock, Backlin, and Fisher 2004a, 2004b, Madden-Smith Ervin, and Fisher 2005). USGS has expanded studies on the arroyo toad to assess impacts from disturbance, management operations, and naturally occurring disturbance such as wildfires and drought (Madden-Smith et al. 2003, Madden-Smith, Ervin, and Fisher 2005, Mendelsohn, Madden-Smith, and Fisher 2005, Brown et al. 2020, Gallegos et al. 2021, Hitchcock et al. 2022). USGS has also continued to refine and improve survey methods, data collection, and analysis methods to better inform status and trends, threats and stressors, and responses of arroyo toads to habitat and water management (Brehme et al. 2006, 2011, 2019).

This project builds on this previous work by USGS and partners to develop and implement a monitoring plan for arroyo toad across San Diego County. 

Background:

The arroyo toad (Anaxyrus californicus) is a habitat specialist endemic to the coastal plains and mountains of central and southern California and northwestern Baja California (Jennings and Hayes 1994). It has a life span of seven to eight years (Fisher et al. 2018). The species primarily inhabits low gradient streams and rivers composed of sandy soils and containing sandy streamside terraces (Sweet 1992 and 1993, Barto 1999). Reproduction depends on availability of shallow, still, or low flow pools in which breeding, egg laying, and tadpole development occur over 65–85 days (Sweet 1992). These habitat requirements are largely determined by natural hydrological cycles and scouring flood events (USFWS 1999, Madden-Smith et al. 2003).  

In 1994, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) listed the arroyo toad as endangered in response to a decline of 75% of its historic distribution within the United States (Jennings and Hayes 1994, USFWS 1994) due to extensive habitat loss, human modification to natural water flow regimes, and introduction of non-native predators. The USFWS released a recovery plan for the arroyo toad in 1999 (USFWS 1999) and reviewed its classification status in 2014, which remained as endangered (USFWS 2015). Arroyo toads were detected in 80% of the 25 his

Monitoring
Vertebrate Species
in progress
Project Groups
  • SDMMP1 Arroyo Toad Monitoring and Management

Project Focus

Arroyo toad

riparian forest & scrub

BODEN CANYON ECOLOGICAL RESERVE, CANADA DE SAN VICENTE, CITY OF SAN DIEGO OPEN SPACE, CLEVELAND NATIONAL FOREST, LONG POTRERO (2006 TOAD/QUINO RECOVERY GRANT), RAMONA GRASSLANDS PRESERVE, SAN LUIS REY RIVER PARK, SAN PASQUAL VALLEY, SANTA MARGARITA PRESERVE, SANTA MARGARITA RIVER PARK, SANTA YSABEL WEST OPEN SPACE PRESERVE, SYCUAN PEAK ECOLOGICAL RESERVE, WILDERNESS GARDENS PRESERVE

Chris Brown

SANDAG; USGS

Robert N. Fisher

U.S. Geological Survey

California Department of Fish & Wildlife; City of San Diego Park and Recreation Department; City of San Diego, Public Utilities Department Watershed and Resource Protection Team; County of San Diego, Department of Parks and Recreation; San Diego National Wildlife Refuge; U.S. Fish and Widlife Service, Carlsbad Fish and Wildlife Office; U.S. Forest Service Cleveland National Forest

Robert N. Fisher

Sarah McCutcheon; Chris Brown

Chris Brown

Cheryl Brehme; Tritia Matsuda; Chris Brown; Denise Clark

Project Protocol
USGS Aquatic Species and Habitat Assessment Protocol for Rivers, Streams, and Creeks

The protocol is designed to standardize survey methods and to specifically determine locality, extent, and status of amphibian species that are threatened, endangered, and of special concern

Data loggers; Visual Encounter Surveys (Daytime Larval Assessments)
706.3KB USGS-DaytimeStreamSurveyProtocol-Paper_April2020.pdf
Strategic Elements
  • FY15-16 - 1.2
Project Location
San Diego
File name Lead Author Year Type
Arroyo Toad and Western Pond Turtle in the San Diego Multiple Species Conservation Program Area, 2002 Meyer, Kathie; Ervin, Edward; Madden-Smith, Melanie; Hathaway, Stacie; Fisher, Robert N. 2003 report
Arroyo toad study design for San Diego County, California Tracey, Jeff; Brehme, Cheryl; Brown, Chris; Rochester, Carlton; Fisher, Robert N. 2020 powerpoint presentation
Arroyo Toads (Bufo californicus) in MCBCP; Findings from 5 years of Population Monitoring and Program Review Brehme, Cheryl; Fisher, Robert N.; Schuster, Sara L.; Turschak, Greta 2010 powerpoint presentation
Aseasonal Flow and Associated Nonnative Species in San Diego: Data Summary Brown, Chris; Perkins, Emily; Hitchcock, Cynthia J.; Aguilar Duran, Angelica; Guerra Salcido, Omar ; Watson, Elise; Fisher, Robert N. 2020 report
Assessing the Risk of Loveland Dam Operations to the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) in the Sweetwater River Channel, San Diego County, California Madden-Smith, Melanie; Atkinson, Andrea; Fisher, Robert N.; Danskin, Wesley R.; Mendez, Gregory O. 2003 report
Baseline Surveys for the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) in the Sweetwater River Channel, San Diego County, California. Madden-Smith, Melanie; Ervin, Edward; Fisher, Robert N. 2005 report
Data Summary for the 2005 Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) Surveys Conducted in the San Bernardino National Forest Schuster, Sara L.; Fisher, Robert N.; Hathaway, Stacie; Backlin, Adam R.; Hitchcock, Cynthia J. 2005 report
Daytime Habitat Assessment Survey Protocol for the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) U.S. Geological Survey, San Diego Field Station 2003 other
Developing a Countywide Arroyo Toad Monitoring Plan San Diego Management and Monitoring Program; U.S. Geological Survey, Western Ecological Research Center 2020 powerpoint presentation
Distribution and Status of the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) and Western Pond Turtle (Emys marmorata) in the San Diego MSCP and Surrounding Areas Final Report 10/11/05 Madden-Smith, Melanie; Ervin, Edward; Meyer, Kathie; Hathaway, Stacie; Fisher, Robert N. 2005 report
Distribution and Status of the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) in the San Diego MSCP and Surrounding Areas, 2002-2003. powerpoint presentation
Draft Final: Associations Between Arroyo Toads, Nonnative Species, Drought, and Impervious Surfaces in San Diego County Brown, Chris; Perkins, Emily; Hitchcock, Cynthia J.; Aguilar Duran, Angelica; Grolle, Lizzie; Watson, Elise; Fisher, Robert N. 2020 report
Habitat Assessment and Surveys for the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) in Cuyamaca Rancho State Park, 2002 Ervin, Edward; Hathaway, Stacie; Fisher, Robert N. 2002 report
Habitat Assessment and Surveys for the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) in Cuyamaca Rancho State Park, and Lucky 5 Ranch in Anza-Borrego Desert State Park, 2003 Ervin, Edward; Fisher, Robert N. 2003 report
Integrating Multiple Distribution Models to Guide Conservation Efforts of an Endangered Toad Treglia, Michael ; Fisher, Robert N.; Fitzgerald, Lee 2015 journal article
Longevity and population age structure of the arroyo southwestern toad (Anaxyrus californicus) with drought implications Fisher, Robert N.; Brehme, Cheryl; Hathaway, Stacie; Hovey, Tim; Warburton, Manna; Stokes, Drew 2018 journal article
MCB Camp Pendleton Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) Monitoring Results, 2003 Brehme, Cheryl; Atkinson, Andrea; Fisher, Robert N. 2004 report
MCB Camp Pendleton Arroyo Toad Monitoring Protocol: 1. Summary of results from a workshop on August 27, 2002 2. Monitoring protocol and targeted studies Atkinson, Andrea; Fisher, Robert N.; Ervin, Edward; Yang, Brian S.; Case, Ted J.; Scott, Norman; Shaffer, H. Bradley 2003 report
MCBCP Arroyo Toad Monitoring Program: 3-Year Trend Analyses for 2003- 2005 Brehme, Cheryl; Schuster, Sara L.; Rochester, Carlton; Hathaway, Stacie; Fisher, Robert N. 2006 report
MCBCP Arroyo Toad Monitoring Results for 2006 with Multi-Year Trend Analysis Turschak, Greta; Brehme, Cheryl; Schuster, Sara L.; Rochester, Carlton; Fisher, Robert N. 2008 report
MCBCP Arroyo Toad Monitoring Results for 2009 with Multi-Year Trend Analysis Brehme, Cheryl; Turschak, Greta; Schuster, Sara L.; Fisher, Robert N. 2011 report
MCBCP Arroyo Toad Monitoring Results for 2011 Brehme, Cheryl; Matsuda, Tritia; Fisher, Robert N. 2012 report
MCBCP Arroyo Toad Monitoring Results for 2012 and Multi-Year Trend Analysis from 2003 to 2012 Brehme, Cheryl; Matsuda, Tritia; Fisher, Robert N. 2013 report
MCBCP Arroyo Toad Monitoring Results for 2013 and Multiyear Trend Analysis from 2003 to 2013 Brehme, Cheryl; Matsuda, Tritia; Fisher, Robert N. 2014 report
Multi-scale effects of land cover and urbanization on the habitat suitability of an endangered toad Treglia, Michael ; Landon, Adam C.; Fisher, Robert N.; Gerard, Kyle; Fitzgerald, Lee 2018 journal article
Range-wide persistence of the endangered arroyo toad (Anaxyrus californicus) for 20+ years following a prolonged drough Hitchcock, Cynthia J.; Gallegos, Elizabeth; Backlin, Adam R.; Barabe, Russell; Bloom, Peter; Boss, Kimberly; Brehme, Cheryl; Brown, Chris; Clark, Denise; Clark, Elizabeth, R.; Cooper, Kevin; Donnell, Julie; Ervin, Edward; Famolaro, Pete; Guilliam, Kim, M.; Hancock, Jacquelyn, J.; Hess, Nicholas; Howard, Steven; Hubbartt, Valerie; Lieske, Patrick; Lovich, Robert; Matsuda, Tritia; Meyer-Wilkins, Katherin; Muri, Kamarul; Nerhus, Barry; Nordland, Jeff; Ortega, Brock; Packard, Robert H.; Ramirez, Ruben; Stewart, Sam, C.; Warburton, Manna; Wells, Jeffery M.; Winkleman, Ryan; Winter, Kirsten; Zitt, Brian; Fisher, Robert N. 2022 journal article
Residence Tract Surveys For: Mountain Yellow-Legged Frog (Rana muscosa), California Red-Legged Frog (Rana aurora) and Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) Backlin, Adam R.; Kahacza, Zsolt; Fisher, Robert N. 2002 report
San Diego Streams Hydroperiod and Aquatic Species Study 2022 - 2024 Williams, Dhafir; Brown, Chris; Fisher, Robert N. 2024 report
Studies of the Arroyo Toad and Coast Range Newt on the Upper San Diego River Watershed - Annual Report Lovio, John; Fleury, Scott; Ervin, Edward; Hathaway, Stacie; Warburton, Manna 2002 report
Studies of the Arroyo Toad and Coast Range Newt on the Upper San Diego River Watershed – Annual Report Technology Associates (TAIC); U.S. Geological Survey, San Diego Field Station 2002 report
Survey Results for the Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) in the San Bernardino National Forest, 2001 Brown, Chris; Fisher, Robert N. 2002 report
Understanding the Demographics of Arroyo Toad (Bufo californicus) Reproduction to Develop Management Strategies. Fisher, Robert N.; Hathaway, Stacie 2002 other